Small Box Smokers Around $2,000: How the Slingshot Stacks Up

Long Burn Basket with the Smokeslinger Pits logo sliding through the front door of a Smokeslinger Slingshot

If you've settled on a small direct heat box cooker, set a budget around $2,000 and want the most cooker that money buys, this one's for you. An independent reviewer, Smoke Master D, just put three personal-size box smokers side by side, and our Slingshot was one of them. Here's what he found, what I'd add, and how to run the same numbers on any cooker you're looking at.

Smoke Master D, "BBQ Buyers' Guide to Affordable, Personal-Size Direct Heat Cookers" (Nov 8, 2026).

Why this price class

A compact box smoker in this range gets you heavy steel and real fire control without stepping up to a $3,000 to $4,000 pit. It's sized for everyday cooks, it fits a patio, and it moves around the yard without a fight. That's the cooker most of the people calling us are actually shopping for.

What the reviewer found

He compared all three on price, grate space, steel, airflow and fire control. On the Slingshot:

  • Most grate space of the three. 506 square inches on one level, and 1,012 with the $99 second grate.
  • Lowest price per square inch, with one grate or two, and the lowest price per pound of steel.
  • Lowest price of the three, at $1,995.
  • 8-inch casters. The other two in his test roll on 4-inch.
  • A double-wall insulated lid, and four half-moon exhausts that let you steer where the smoke and heat go.
  • His verdict: "incredibly versatile… a very good choice."

Two things have changed since he filmed. The Forever basket is now $217, and a Slingshot cover is coming before the end of the year.

Run the numbers yourself

This is the same math we use in our direct heat buying guide. It works on any cooker, ours or anybody's.

  1. Price per square inch of grate that comes in the box. Slingshot: $1,995 ÷ 506 = $3.94. Add the $99 second grate and it's $2,094 ÷ 1,012 = $2.07.
  2. Cooking modes with what ships in the price. Slingshot: five. Offset, reverse flow, embers on bottom, 90-minute and reverse sear.
  3. Price per square inch, per mode. $3.94 ÷ 5 = $0.79. With the second grate, $0.41.
  4. Cost to your first cook. The Slingshot's price includes the Long Burn Basket, five tuning plates, a round-bar grate, a thermometer, the insulated and gasketed lid and 8-inch casters, and it's rotisserie-ready. On any cooker you're comparing, check whether these are in the price or sold extra: a fire grate or basket, a second grate, tuning plates, a grilling basket, side tables. Add the extras in before you compare.

Fill it in for any cooker:

Your cooker Slingshot
Price with everything you need for the first cook $1,995
Included grate area (sq in) 506
Price ÷ grate area $3.94
Cooking modes, no add-ons 5
Price per sq in, per mode $0.79

Simple when you want it

Some folks want the simplest box there is, and that's fair. On day one the Slingshot runs exactly like one: Long Burn Basket in the middle, fire under the food, lid down. The tuning plates and the four dampers wait until you want them. Slide the basket to one end and set the plates, and it cooks like an offset. Set them the other way and it's reverse flow, or two zones, hot on one side and gentle on the other.

Smokeslinger Slingshot with the Long Burn Basket centered on the pit floor, tuning plates at the back, top view

What about a drum?

A drum is a good cooker that does one thing well. The Long Burn Basket burns top-down the way a drum does, built for long, steady cooks. The Slingshot adds offset, reverse flow, two-zone, embers on bottom and the 90-minute cook, with room for two full-width grate levels instead of one round grate.

Inside the Long Burn Basket in a Smokeslinger Slingshot, showing its sloped walls and perforated floor

Can it sear?

The reviewer figured the Slingshot was built more for long cooks than high-heat grilling. He hadn't cooked on one yet, so here's what it does: it sears hard.

The Long Burn Basket gets very hot on its own. For the hottest sear, set the Forever basket on the pit floor and build a big wood-and-charcoal fire under the open plate gap. My tri-tip off that setup came out with a heavy crust and the fat still bubbling on the surface.

If searing is the main event for you, the Mini gets the coals closer. Its fire sits right up on the tuning plates, just under the meat. On the Slingshot the fire stays on the floor, a little farther away, and it still puts a real crust on.

He also brought up steel thickness. The Slingshot is ⅛-inch USA steel, and it cooks the same as our ¼-inch pits. A box cooker holds its heat in the lid, and the Slingshot has the same double-wall, air-gap insulated, gasketed lid as the Mini and Full Size. The difference you'll notice is weight. At about 275 pounds, it's easy to move.

Who's behind it

The reviewer pointed out something most buyers don't expect: you can call us. Every Smokeslinger is built to order by Dustin McCormack in Kaufman, Texas, about 8 weeks from your down payment. Call or text 762-772-2727 and you'll get me or Lisa.

Get your delivered price

Request a quote on the Slingshot and a real person prices your pit and freight to your zip. Still deciding? The buying guide lays out all three direct heat cookers side by side, and Slingshot vs. Mini covers the two most people choose between. You can also see both small smokers on one page.

Request a quote on the Slingshot

Small box smoker FAQ

Can the Slingshot sear steaks?

Yes, and hot. The Long Burn Basket gets very hot on its own, and the Forever basket on the pit floor with a big wood-and-charcoal fire goes hotter still. If searing is your main cook, the Mini gets the coals even closer because its fire sits up on the tuning plates.

How is the Slingshot different from a drum smoker?

Its Long Burn Basket burns top-down the way a drum does, for long, steady cooks. The Slingshot also runs offset, reverse flow, two-zone, embers on bottom and the 90-minute cook, with room for two full-width grate levels.

Does ⅛-inch steel hold heat as well as ¼-inch?

It cooks the same. A box cooker holds its heat in the lid, and the Slingshot uses the same double-wall, air-gap insulated, gasketed lid as the Mini and Full Size. The difference is weight: about 275 pounds.

How long does it take to get a Slingshot?

It's built to order in Kaufman, Texas, about 8 weeks from your down payment. We deliver by freight anywhere in the lower 48, or you can pick it up at the shop by appointment. Request a quote for your delivered price.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Recipes, Reviews & Comparisons

Two chickens turning on a rotisserie spit above the grate of a Full Size Smokeslinger, with ribs and vegetables cooking below
Smoker Rotisserie and Add-Ons: Every Smokeslinger Option Explained

October 29, 2026 5 min read

Add a rotisserie, plancha, lid counterweight or cover to your Smokeslinger. What each option does, which pits it fits, and what it costs.

Weld where the round firebox meets the cook chamber on a Liberty94 offset smoker
Custom Offset Smoker vs. Production Offset: What "Custom" Really Means

October 26, 2026 4 min read

Thinking about a custom offset smoker? What custom really means, what it costs you in time and risk, the engineering details that make any offset cook well, and when a proven production offset is the smarter buy.

Mini Smokeslinger direct heat cooker, front view
Slingshot vs. Mini: Which Compact Direct Heat Cooker Fits You?

October 13, 2026 5 min read

The Slingshot and the Mini are our two compact direct heat cookers. Here's how the movable basket, the center drawer, searing, steel and price stack up, so you can pick the one that fits how you cook.